Primers, eh? Some people love them, some people think they're a giant scam. Then there's the search for the exact right one for you. Me, I'm on the fence. I use them, but I don't really love them. My favourite is Face of Australia Face Base, but it doesn't do a lot to extend the life of my makeup, it just feels nice and adds a smooth base so my face doesn't feel tight during the day. As for eye primers, I'm one of those who thinks good old UDPP is highly over-rated. It does nothing to combat oily eyelids and creasing for me - in fact, I prefer my $7 NYX eye primer, and even that's not so great. I haven't tried TFSI, which I'm told is the bomb. It's on my wishlist - I intend to get some this year. Lately I've been having some luck with Coastal Scents Shadow Worx - it's way better than UDPP for me, and seems to stay the distance pretty well.
Garnier Miracle Skin Perfector Daily All-in-One BB Cream: I hated this stuff when I first used it, BB cream my arse. I thought I'd thrown it out, and when Anita did a post about how she used it for primer with great success, I was all, "Awwww, missed opportunity. Sad face." But then I found it in a drawer (it was the medium one I gave away - early Alzheimer's alert!) - it really is a miracle! It does make a nice enough primer. Terrible, terrible BB Cream, though. Terrible even for a tinted moisturiser, which is exactly what it is.
Face of Australia Face Base 3 in 1: I love the original so I had high hopes for this version with sunscreen included. It's very sunscreeny. That's all I have to say about it. I do use it in summer, though - every little bit counts. (Oh, and by the way - Miracle Skin Perfector - no sunscreen!)
Face of Australia Face Base Primer with Vitamin E and Chamomile: Aaaaah, my old favourite. I've been using this for a few years, ever since a lovely girl on the Beauty Heaven forums (who seems to have disappeared, as I did from there when it kept getting too dramariffic) recommended it. Cheap as chips and gives me a nice base to work over. As I said above though, does nowt to increase the longevity of one's face. On me, anyway.
Benefit The Porefessional: Meh. Super expensive product that in my opinion isn't worth the price. It does initially do some smoothening (it's a word - I made it one ages ago) of the pores and wrinkly bits, but it makes my face feel greasy after a while, no matter how tiny an amount I use. And it certainly doesn't keep my makeup on all day. I use it occasionally around my t-zone and that's about it.
L'Oreal Base Magique Transforming Smoothing Primer: I was sent this to trial by Beauty Heaven, and I find it has similar issues to The Porefessional. I also really dislike the jar packaging - I hate sticking my fingers in primers and things. It should at least come with a wee spatula like the Clarins Instant Smooth Perfecting Touch (which this is very similar to) does. No likey.
NYX HD High Definition Eye Shadow Base: Looks, feels and acts exactly like UDPP, but on me lasts a bit better. Not fantastic, but good enough for most normal days.
Urban Decay Primer Potion: Along with Clarins Beauty Flash Balm and Estee Lauder Advanced Night Repair, one of those cult products that everyone loves but does pretty much nothing for me. I always seem to have at least one around because they come free with palettes and stuff, but I've never bought one.
Coastal Scents Shadow Worx: Surprisingly good! I'm not a fan of Coastal Scents in general, but they knocked one out of the park here. And you only need a teeny bit so it will last FOREVER. I think they come in different formulations (matte, shimmer, etc), but I just have a bog standard one. Definitely my most used.
Detrivore Cosmetics Eye Primer: Not really a "primer" primer as such - more of a base. I still need to have UDPP or Shadow Worx or something under it as it does nothing to stop creasing, but it's great for making colours brighter. I use it with any loose shadows as it helps them to stick as well.
NYX Eyeshadow Base White: Again, a base rather than a primer, and does nothing to stop creasing or fading. It does make colours brighter though, pretty much a pot version of the NYX Milk Jumbo Eye Pencil, but not as thick. I usually use it for swatching and not much else.
So that's it, again pretty much a reasonably sized collection. Don't worry, folks - Crazy Town is definitely on the itinerary. We'll get there soon!
Interesting primer collection, I've used about three primers, like the FOA one. It's one of those things I never usually bother with when I'm putting my face on.
ReplyDeleteI'm still up in the air about whether or not they are completely necessary. I don't always use one, but I tend to be more religious about it in hot weather.
Deletehrm, you've piqued my interest in the shadow worx primer! i kinda like the packaging too. :)
ReplyDeleteI had pretty low expectations of it, so it was a pleasant surprise to find it worked as well as it did.
DeleteI like primers, but I guess I use them a bit differently. I often don't wear foundation, so I use them to give my blush something to cling to!
ReplyDeleteFOA is my favourite so far, while Napoleon Perdis is my most-hated, I don't understand why people rave!
I do like Smashbox primer (the clear one) under foundation at night events, it does seem to stop shiny ghost face when I have my picture taken with a flash.
I haven't tried Napoleon but I found the Smashbox one too heavy and clingy. I could feel it on my face for hours and it bugged the hell out of me!
DeleteYou know what else is a surprisingly good eye primer..ELF mineral primer. It's $3 and I thought it worked just as well if not better than most of the high end ones. I also like MAC painterly. For my face, I'm back & forth whether I need one or not. In the summer I've been using Paula Begoun's mattifying face primer and I like it.
ReplyDeleteI've never tried any of the MAC paint pots, can you believe it! They're on my 'one of these days' list. :-)
DeleteI kind of like the L'Oreal. It's nice and mattifying for us oil slick types.
ReplyDeleteAnd I've stopped buying things that claim to do something for pores. Never works!
Yeah, I think it's a product that is good for oily skin, but not necessarily other skin types.
DeleteI don't have any face primers but I have a grand total of TWO eye primers which I alternate between, usually when the weather's hot and I don't want my eyeshadow sliding onto my cheeks or if I want to up the amp for a night out!
ReplyDeleteI'm not sure everyone needs a primer - it certainly benefits some people, and in hot weather I use them a lot. But I don't get into them so much in winter.
DeleteUDPP and TFSI both make a world of difference to how long eyeshadow lasts on me. But face primers do nothing for me. Sometimes I think I just haven't found the right one, but I hardly ever use it anyway.
ReplyDeleteLooking forward to your eyeshadow inventory!!!
I think primers only help certain skin types - there aren't too many that I've found that do all that much for me.
DeleteThis post has saved me at least £30 cos I was planning on buying the Garnier BB and the Porefessional. Now I'm not. Yay!!
ReplyDeleteDoes that count as community service? ;-)
Delete