Tuesday, February 28, 2012

Inventory 2012: Primers

Primers, eh? Some people love them, some people think they're a giant scam. Then there's the search for the exact right one for you. Me, I'm on the fence. I use them, but I don't really love them. My favourite is Face of Australia Face Base, but it doesn't do a lot to extend the life of my makeup, it just feels nice and adds a smooth base so my face doesn't feel tight during the day. As for eye primers, I'm one of those who thinks good old UDPP is highly over-rated. It does nothing to combat oily eyelids and creasing for me - in fact, I prefer my $7 NYX eye primer, and even that's not so great. I haven't tried TFSI, which I'm told is the bomb. It's on my wishlist - I intend to get some this year. Lately I've been having some luck with Coastal Scents Shadow Worx - it's way better than UDPP for me, and seems to stay the distance pretty well.


Garnier Miracle Skin Perfector Daily All-in-One BB Cream: I hated this stuff when I first used it, BB cream my arse. I thought I'd thrown it out, and when Anita did a post about how she used it for primer with great success, I was all, "Awwww, missed opportunity. Sad face." But then I found it in a drawer (it was the medium one I gave away - early Alzheimer's alert!) - it really is a miracle! It does make a nice enough primer. Terrible, terrible BB Cream, though. Terrible even for a tinted moisturiser, which is exactly what it is.

Face of Australia Face Base 3 in 1: I love the original so I had high hopes for this version with sunscreen included. It's very sunscreeny. That's all I have to say about it. I do use it in summer, though - every little bit counts. (Oh, and by the way - Miracle Skin Perfector - no sunscreen!)

Face of Australia Face Base Primer with Vitamin E and Chamomile: Aaaaah, my old favourite. I've been using this for a few years, ever since a lovely girl on the Beauty Heaven forums (who seems to have disappeared, as I did from there when it kept getting too dramariffic) recommended it. Cheap as chips and gives me a nice base to work over. As I said above though, does nowt to increase the longevity of one's face. On me, anyway.

Benefit The Porefessional: Meh. Super expensive product that in my opinion isn't worth the price. It does initially do some smoothening (it's a word - I made it one ages ago) of the pores and wrinkly bits, but it makes my face feel greasy after a while, no matter how tiny an amount I use. And it certainly doesn't keep my makeup on all day. I use it occasionally around my t-zone and that's about it.

L'Oreal Base Magique Transforming Smoothing Primer: I was sent this to trial by Beauty Heaven, and I find it has similar issues to The Porefessional. I also really dislike the jar packaging - I hate sticking my fingers in primers and things. It should at least come with a wee spatula like the Clarins Instant Smooth Perfecting Touch (which this is very similar to) does. No likey.


NYX HD High Definition Eye Shadow Base: Looks, feels and acts exactly like UDPP, but on me lasts a bit better. Not fantastic, but good enough for most normal days.

Urban Decay Primer Potion: Along with Clarins Beauty Flash Balm and Estee Lauder Advanced Night Repair, one of those cult products that everyone loves but does pretty much nothing for me. I always seem to have at least one around because they come free with palettes and stuff, but I've never bought one.

Coastal Scents Shadow Worx: Surprisingly good! I'm not a fan of Coastal Scents in general, but they knocked one out of the park here. And you only need a teeny bit so it will last FOREVER. I think they come in different formulations (matte, shimmer, etc), but I just have a bog standard one. Definitely my most used.

Detrivore Cosmetics Eye Primer: Not really a "primer" primer as such - more of a base. I still need to have UDPP or Shadow Worx or something under it as it does nothing to stop creasing, but it's great for making colours brighter. I use it with any loose shadows as it helps them to stick as well. 

NYX Eyeshadow Base White: Again, a base rather than a primer, and does nothing to stop creasing or fading. It does make colours brighter though, pretty much a pot version of the NYX Milk Jumbo Eye Pencil, but not as thick. I usually use it for swatching and not much else.

So that's it, again pretty much a reasonably sized collection. Don't worry, folks - Crazy Town is definitely on the itinerary. We'll get there soon!

16 comments:

  1. Interesting primer collection, I've used about three primers, like the FOA one. It's one of those things I never usually bother with when I'm putting my face on.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm still up in the air about whether or not they are completely necessary. I don't always use one, but I tend to be more religious about it in hot weather.

      Delete
  2. hrm, you've piqued my interest in the shadow worx primer! i kinda like the packaging too. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I had pretty low expectations of it, so it was a pleasant surprise to find it worked as well as it did.

      Delete
  3. I like primers, but I guess I use them a bit differently. I often don't wear foundation, so I use them to give my blush something to cling to!
    FOA is my favourite so far, while Napoleon Perdis is my most-hated, I don't understand why people rave!

    I do like Smashbox primer (the clear one) under foundation at night events, it does seem to stop shiny ghost face when I have my picture taken with a flash.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I haven't tried Napoleon but I found the Smashbox one too heavy and clingy. I could feel it on my face for hours and it bugged the hell out of me!

      Delete
  4. You know what else is a surprisingly good eye primer..ELF mineral primer. It's $3 and I thought it worked just as well if not better than most of the high end ones. I also like MAC painterly. For my face, I'm back & forth whether I need one or not. In the summer I've been using Paula Begoun's mattifying face primer and I like it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've never tried any of the MAC paint pots, can you believe it! They're on my 'one of these days' list. :-)

      Delete
  5. I kind of like the L'Oreal. It's nice and mattifying for us oil slick types.

    And I've stopped buying things that claim to do something for pores. Never works!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, I think it's a product that is good for oily skin, but not necessarily other skin types.

      Delete
  6. I don't have any face primers but I have a grand total of TWO eye primers which I alternate between, usually when the weather's hot and I don't want my eyeshadow sliding onto my cheeks or if I want to up the amp for a night out!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm not sure everyone needs a primer - it certainly benefits some people, and in hot weather I use them a lot. But I don't get into them so much in winter.

      Delete
  7. UDPP and TFSI both make a world of difference to how long eyeshadow lasts on me. But face primers do nothing for me. Sometimes I think I just haven't found the right one, but I hardly ever use it anyway.

    Looking forward to your eyeshadow inventory!!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think primers only help certain skin types - there aren't too many that I've found that do all that much for me.

      Delete
  8. This post has saved me at least £30 cos I was planning on buying the Garnier BB and the Porefessional. Now I'm not. Yay!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Does that count as community service? ;-)

      Delete